From the pulpit, a good and holy priest once spoke of the difference between fruitfulness and productivity. “It is fruitfulness,” he said, “that God asks of us, not productivity.” The statement was baffling. Couldn’t the two terms could be used to mean the same thing? Certainly they are interchangeable. Eventually however, after much interior confrontation and justification, the vast difference between the actual meanings of both words became evident.
Accepting those differences did not make it any easier to accept the priest’s statement. Searching the Scriptures only made it harder to dispute his words. In both Old and New Testaments we are urged to be fruitful, to bear fruit. It doesn’t say a word about being productive. Yes, the people we read about in Scripture did many good things; they tended sheep, made journeys and took chances. Some even led armies and kingdoms. But none of the things they did take center stage when it comes to their significance in the history of our salvation; their earthly accomplishments appear only as incidentals, back-drops at best.
Productivity, in our world, refers to our temporal accomplishments; it has a beginning and an end. Even if its carried on for generations, productivity, as we understand it today, eventually ends where it begins – here on earth.
Fruitfulness, however, as it is used in Scripture, speaks of an eternal process of the “new” which moves forward, changes course, corrects its own weaknesses, and continues – even if unnoticed – centuries later. It does not end here on earth. Fruitfulness is the one activity of life which jumps the great divide and lives on in the Spirit, bridging the gap between life and death.
Productivity is comforting – an immediate reward in compensation for exhaustion and for the lack of personal time for relationships and altruistic endeavors. It promises security. It feels good to look back over the day and enumerate accomplishments. It is the basis for hiring and firing. Productivity is the number one ice breaker at dinner parties and other social gatherings. “So, what do you do?” Our pre-recorded automatic responses glide importantly from our lips and, for good measure, we throw in brief summaries of planned future productivity.
Fruitfulness is something altogether different. The process is not always comforting. In fact, when its meaning is broken down it is not very appealing (no pun intended). It carries no tangible assurances, or promises which are immediately recognizable. It requires waiting, and waiting… It carries with it the stigma of the appearance of inertia even though it takes great effort. It appears counter-productive and definitely counter-cultural. I can’t brag about it at dinner parties.
There’s not much going on with a piece of fruit. In fact, the word vegetative springs to mind with all its negative social implications. I can go outside, pull up a chair and sit, and carefully watch a piece of fruit all day, all week, all month and not see a thing. It just sort of hangs around attached to a tree limb. It doesn’t protect itself from weather, birds or insects. It hangs on…until, of course, I pick it off the tree and eat it or, if it falls off, it just lays on the ground, immobile once again – to be consumed ever further by birds and insects. Either way, the core decomposes and the seeds that aren’t eaten get covered up with dirt and leaves. Okay. Graduation complete – Fruit 101.
Here’ s what I learned:
- A piece of fruit is not its own – not from the beginning of its existence and not at the end.
- It lives by staying attached to its life source.
- Fruit is immobile – except, of course, when outside forces intersect with it.
- Fruit is completely vulnerable; it has no defense mechanisms.
- Fruit has a short life-expectancy.
- The sole purpose of fruit’s existence is to be fully consumed – both inside and out.
- Fruit is not capable of contributing to its purpose. That depends on its life source and the hunger and attentiveness of the people and creatures around it.
- Fruit surrounds and protects its seeds, carrying them deep within its flesh. (Vegetables, in scientific descriptions explaining the difference between fruit and vegetables, do not.) The Bible doesn’t’ say, “Be vegetative.”
- To reach its full purpose, fruit must be first of all consumed, and the seeds it bore must fall to the ground, dry up and be covered over with earth.
- Its seeds are not recognizable as fruit.
- The fruit which bore the seeds is forgotten.
- Finally, the seeds, when covered over, are forgotten as well.
- From what appears to be dried up and dead, from that which is covered over, unnoticed and forgotten, comes life – a completely new tree.
- The new tree is not recognizable as the continuation of the one, specific piece of fruit from which it grew.
- But it is.
So what was that priest trying to say? What was God saying when He told Adam and Noah, Abraham and Jacob and Moses, Jeremiah and Ezekiel that He would make them fruitful? What was Jesus saying when He told His followers to bear fruit?
Is this process called ‘fruitfulness’ what God expects of me?
The answer did not come easily. It required destruction, vulnerability and an uncomfortable trust. It required letting go and exposing once carefully protected assumptions and parts of my identity. It involved death on many levels. The answer was yes.
Today we celebrate Pentecost, the Birthday of the Church. We celebrate the Promise of the Father, which comes to us from the short but fruitful life of Jesus, from His willingness to be vulnerable to outside forces, His refusal to defend or protect Himself, His trust in the Father… and His death.
The Feast of Pentecost honors the moment in our salvation history when the Holy Spirit came upon the Apostles – over-took them in a way – as they were hiding, afraid to move or to do anything to call attention to themselves, for fear of death. There, as they huddled together, alone and uncertain, covered over like so many dried up seeds, He came to them – right where they were.
Scripture tells us that they became “filled with the Holy Spirit” – with new life. And suddenly they were able to speak in such a way that everyone, no matter their language, understood them perfectly! The Scriptures for the Feast of Pentecost tell us that the people who heard the apostles were “confused” and “astounded.” They marveled, “How does each of us hear them in our native language?”
This phenomenon, this miracle, which took place over two thousand years ago – the fruitfulness of the Word of God made flesh – is not over.
Every time we hear the Scriptures and “something new” becomes immediately apparent to us, we are hearing that Word in our own heart-language. The man sitting next to us in the pew hears something else. Every time we hear a sermon and feel challenged, confused, or even defensive, we are experiencing Pentecost, hearing in our own language what the Holy Spirit enables us to hear. We taste the fruit of the life which springs, ever new, from the Word of God. We experience the Holy Spirit and the gifts of wisdom, knowledge and understanding that He brings with Him.
We become part of the perennial miracle of Pentecost.
Happy Feast Day!